Settling vs. Going to Trial: Weighing Your Options in Personal Injury Cases

When clients are involved in an accident due to someone else’s negligence, deciding whether to settle the personal injury claim or take it to trial is a big decision. Discussing with a personal injury lawyer Plymouth, MA, is essential for a positive outcome. This critical choice can significantly impact the result of a case and the compensation a client will receive. As experienced Plymouth MA lawyers, weighing these options and helping clients make informed decisions are essential to ensure the decision aligns with their best interests.

Settling Your Personal Injury Claim

Settling a personal injury claim involves agreeing with the at-fault party or their insurance company without going to court. In many cases, settlements are achieved through negotiations between legal representation and the other party’s representatives. Here are some key points our personal injury lawyer Plymouth MA wants clients to consider when contemplating settling their personal injury claim:

Certainty and Timeliness

Going to trial can be a lengthy and unpredictable process, with the possibility of appeals prolonging the resolution. In contrast, settling a claim allows clients to receive compensation faster and move forward with life.

Control over the Outcome

Settling opens the door for a personal injury lawyer Plymouth, to negotiate the settlement terms and decide whether to accept the offer. This control empowers clients to choose based on their unique circumstances and priorities.

Avoiding the Stress of Litigation

Personal injury trials can be emotionally and mentally taxing, as they involve presenting evidence, witnesses, and arguments before a judge and jury. Settling a claim can spare the client and their loved ones from the stress of the courtroom.


Settlements are often kept confidential, which means that the terms and details of the agreement are not made public. This privacy can appeal to some individuals who prefer to keep their matters private.

Going to Trial: The Advantages and Considerations

Choosing to go to trial means allowing a judge and jury to decide the outcome of the personal injury case. While trials can be more time-consuming and uncertain, there are circumstances where going to trial with a personal injury lawyer Plymouth MA, may be the best course of action:

Pursuing Maximum Compensation

If the at-fault party or their insurance company is unwilling to offer a fair settlement, going to trial may be necessary to seek the maximum compensation the victim deserves.

Establishing Liability and Accountability

In some cases, going to trial can be essential to establish liability and hold the responsible party accountable for their actions. A trial can provide a public forum to present evidence and arguments demonstrating the other party’s negligence.

Setting Legal Precedents

When going to trial, this allows a contribution to developing personal injury law and may help protect the rights of future accident victims.

Make the Right Decision with a Personal Injury Lawyer Plymouth from Law Offices of John C. Manoog III

If you are involved in an accident and need to know the next steps, contact the Law Offices of John C. Manoog III and let our seasoned professionals help. With our expertise, we can ensure we will guide our clients in the right direction when filing a claim. To learn more about how our Plymouth MA lawyers can help, schedule a free consultation and talk to a professional today!

Contact Information